Is Astrology for real?

Shekhar25 · Apr 10th, 2006, 04:25

Hi folks,
This question always eluded me. Even though I look for facts for anything I need to believe in, there are some things which I just cannot explain with science. One such amazing thing is "ASTROLOGY" (remember not astronomy even though they are linked somewhat in the concept).

I have seen some amazing details with accuracy told by some astrologers in India (either about things happening to a country in the future or how a person changes in the future etc).
I now feel, there must be two reasons to explain this vedic science (as the hindus put it), either it is an amazing coincidence or there must be some effect of planets on human beings.

Science does believe in the later explanation. So, does anyone has any ideas of how astrology really works with amazing accuracy?
How did the ancient Hindus learn to grasp such a science?

or Is it completely hoax?
Last but not least, did anyone hear about Bejan Daruwala? If so, what do you think about him?

I'll look forward for your open-minded replies on this topic.
Thank you
--Shekhar

sunilg · Apr 10th, 2006, 04:51

you have answered your question:

"modern science doesn't have answer for everything;" and that is the area where astrology works. Its just like God, nobody has seen him/her , but most of us do believe he/she exists.

I believe its science. Even if you think that its nothing more than making fool of people; but then making fool is an art and there is science behind every art. Just think how great psychologists these astrologers are; they can make you believe that a ball of stones/metals/gases/etc. can change your life from thousands of light years away even if there is no life on itself

PeakXV · Apr 10th, 2006, 05:12

Most probably it is the astrologer's ability to foretell certain aspects of your future by observing your present demeanor, current state of mind , and details of your past. Package it all with the obligatory smoke and mirrors from the movements and motions of the heavenly bodies and an astute people person has themselves a gig. Are they ever right? - yeah even a blind squirrel can find a nut or two!

crvlvr · Apr 10th, 2006, 23:51

Astrology may be for real. But I have yet to meet someone who can predict the future accurately.

vinatara · Apr 11th, 2006, 00:02

I know an astrologer who can generate teh horoscope and list down the future with just birth date , time and place. He neednt see or know the person or his/her name!

May be its a science and we just dont understand completely.
Imagine how a village beggar would think about how an online trading really works if you demo it to him!!!!!

cyberhippie · Apr 11th, 2006, 00:19

I was once told by an astrologer I travelled with (he was a Romany gypsy) that on a particula day I should be careful as there was a major chance of cutting myself!!
I didn't the boss did and he, we later found out shared my birth date!!

I'm not knowledgable enough about astrology to see the science in this but it really took me by suprise!!

crvlvr · Apr 11th, 2006, 01:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by cyberhippie

I was once told by an astrologer I travelled with (he was a Romany gypsy) that on a particula day I should be careful as ther was a major chance of cutting myself!!

Even the best astrologers can only point to tendencies and probabilities. I have not seen any proof that any one's accuracy ever higher than 50%. But just like ine gambling, where people's tend to remember their wins and forget their losses, people tend to remember the astrologer's predictions when they hold true.

Quote:

Originally Posted by vinatara

I know an astrologer who can generate teh horoscope and list down the future with just birth date , time and place

thats exactly how vedic astrology horoscopes are generated -- using birth date and time and latitude and longitude of birthplace. no other information is required.

I agree with PeakXV's assessment, most astrologers are quacks. Especially those who try to sell you amulets and crystals to ward off evil spirits.

dhans · Apr 11th, 2006, 01:43

They did do a nice experoiment in the Netherlands with astrologers. From a given three page profile they had to tell what the birthsign was. Result less than one out of twelve was right. Even less than might be expected form a sheer gamble.

And imagine. You read your horoscope in the paper in the morning and you know that 500 million people will experience exactly the same as you during the day.

Nice science astrology...

Hans

alcoholv · Apr 11th, 2006, 02:07

Astrology is real and their is no question about it. But it not astrology which determines your fate.Before reading this Great book , I was under the impression that what ever the astrologer says , we shall become..but that is not the case after reading the below book.

If you read " Vasistha Yoga", Vasistha Clearly says to Rama , that man is the maker of destiny not fate. If you are not able to attain somethins then you are not putting more effort to attain. If you just wait for things to happen it is fate...

Thanks.

rangss · Apr 11th, 2006, 02:40