India Travel Forum | IndiaMike.com

India Travel Forum | IndiaMike.com (http://www.indiamike.com/india/)
-   Indian Wildlife and National Parks (http://www.indiamike.com/india/indian-wildlife-and-national-parks-f74/)
-   -   Appeal for action on Keoladeo Ghana National Park, Bharatpur (http://www.indiamike.com/india/indian-wildlife-and-national-parks-f74/appeal-for-action-on-keoladeo-ghana-national-park-bharatpur-t9693/)

Alan D Jan 15th, 2005 19:58

Keoladeo Ghana NP Bharatpur - "Disaster Area"
 
For anyone planning to visit this bird sanctuary, this is an email I just received from an Indian friend in Delhi.

Quote:

"Yes, i did visit Bharatur this Jan , The place is a
disaster zone with NO WATER, NOT EVEN A DROP; this despite a relatively
good monsoon the last season; the surrounding villages refused to let out
the dammed waters from the feeder Karoli dam; the sanctuary has got badly
embroiled in the local water politics; the issue is though quite
complex : a man made marshland right in the midst of Thar desert! But there is hope in that several local nature organisations have come together on a save Bird Sanctuary platform at a Jaipur based Bird watching festival;

Srichand of the sanctuary told me of a pipeline from Chambal on its way to the sanctuary, but was skeptical as the local city population too wants a share from it."
If anyone is expecting to see thousands of ducks, geese, herons, egrets, storks, spoonbills, ibises etc then they are going to be mightily disappointed.

If however you want to potter around for a couple of days a lot of the dry area birds will still be there, as well as monkeys, spotted deer, nilgai and pythons.

radz Jan 15th, 2005 21:24

Had been to there last week,yes no water ,if we expect thousands of birds then will be disappointed.
As one day stopover on the way to Jaipur TO Agra can try.

Radz

phreako1 Jan 15th, 2005 21:28

:dontgetit

kaushiks Jan 17th, 2005 16:31

I went a year back there were lots of birds. It might still be worth if you are from Delhi but I hear it getting worse fast.

Alan D Jan 17th, 2005 16:58

For the background to my post, see this thread from last year posted by bijapuri.

As posted by cyberhippie the release of water for the park seemed decided at the time. I wonder what happened?

I'm aware that there are competing demands for the available water but the reserve is a major source of employment for the town, as well as being one of the most important wetland reserves in the world.

I feel like sending emails off to all and sundry! [cry]

pkalra Jan 17th, 2005 20:13

Feel So Sad !!!!

ashish0608 Jan 18th, 2005 12:47

situation is worse than this
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan D
I feel like sending emails off to all and sundry! [cry]

AlanD I think we should.. most fingers are being pointed at the CM of Rajasthan.

The birds are being eaten:
I read it in the papers today that finding no-place in the bird sanctuary the birds are taking refuge in un-protected areas around banks of Ganga and are being killed for food... Brajghat, western-UP is where the killing incidents are being reported and the authorities can't do anything :mad: One person who is fond of the foreign birds..even said "as the birds come from cold countries eating them gives us better protection for the cold" :mad:

ddutta Jan 18th, 2005 13:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by ashish0608
One person who is fond of the foreign birds..even said "as the birds come from cold countries eating them gives us better protection for the cold" :mad:

I am totally shocked & confused. :confused: [shock] :confused: [shock] :confused: [shock] .

cyberhippie Jan 18th, 2005 14:40

Politics politics!!
The truth of the matter is there was enough water in the reservior, both for the park and for the human/agricultural needs!!
The non release of the water was purely politics!!! The park has become a pawn in some mysterious political game that only a politician could understand!!
On a slightly more upbeat note I would still recommend a visit to the park as althought the cormerant and stork nurserys are missing the park still has much to offer for the bird watcher as well as a great selection of mammals like jungle cat, jackal, nilgai and spotted deer. You can see all these on any given day in the park and of course it's still the only park that allows you to freely wander around on a bicycle!!
Please support this park and the hotels around it as the tour groups have already abndoned it to a large extent leaving the local hoteliers struggling to make a living!!
Have a look, with or without the migratory birds this park still warrents a visit!!

Happy Traveling !1

Alan D Jan 18th, 2005 18:35

I forgot to put the link in my previous post!

I agree with cyberhippie that the park is still worth a visit as I'm sure the park naturalists, rickshaw drivers and the hoteliers around the park are probably having a lean time. You just won't see the spectacular numbers of water birds that normally are found there at this time of year. You can still rent a bike, take a packed lunch and thermos of tea and explore the many side tracks that lead off the main metalled road that runs through the park. There's also the slim chance of seeing the tiger, thought to have made its way from Ranthambore, that's been hanging around the park for a couple of seasons now.

Is anyone actually aware of the "political" issues involved and, if so, can you explain them please?

What ashish says makes sense - if there is no water in the park then they go somewhere else where protection cannot be guaranteed. This could have a long term effect on the numbers of migrant birds arriving in the park in the future.

Any suggestions as to who to send an email to - CM of Rajasthan? Union Minister for Tourism? Local Bharatpur MLA? any others?

ashish0608 Jan 18th, 2005 19:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan D
Is anyone actually aware of the "political" issues involved and, if so, can you explain them please?

What ashish says makes sense - if there is no water in the park then they go somewhere else where protection cannot be guaranteed. This could have a long term effect on the numbers of migrant birds arriving in the park in the future.

Any suggestions as to who to send an email to - CM of Rajasthan? Union Minister for Tourism? Local Bharatpur MLA? any others?


To the best of my understanding:

There was (as they say) shortage of water and options were 1)to keep the water for irrigation/farmers or 2)leave it for birds and the state govt. decided in favour of the farmers by leaving very little water for the birds. You see the birds don't vote, the people who come to watch them don't also vote (most of them don't vote in Rajasthan) and the farmers vote.

The key point analysis now is 'Is there really any shortage'? if No, 100% blame goes on the State Govt. and mesures should be taken to prevent further damage and repair the damage already done

The mails should be sent to all of the above and also to many more...our fellows will read only the mails where the copies are sent to many including to some international bodies. (Bhartpur is in the UN list of natural parks and protected areas)

pkalra Feb 9th, 2005 05:50

take action
 
http://www.sanctuaryasia.com/takeact...n_keoladeo.php

bijapuri Feb 9th, 2005 12:55

no water, I can't believe it . . .a crime!

the fort is worth a look, especially the evening puja, and there's a temple outside the walls with a croccodile goddess!

If you're in Delhi (and wanting to get a feel for the RaJ) the Imperial Hotel has a splendid collection of color lithographs of Bharatpur on the walls of the ground floor.

. . . Felt snubbed and ignored at afternoon tea, tho :mad:

Alan D Feb 9th, 2005 17:45

pkalra

Thanks for posting the above link.

I think it deserves separate thread

Alan D Feb 9th, 2005 18:08

Appeal for action on Keoladeo Ghana National Park, Bharatpur
 
As a frequent visitor to this internationally important wetland reserve ,I would appeal to all others on the forum who have visited and enjoyed the diversity of its birdlife, and those who are just interested in preserving India's wildlife generally, to take a couple of minutes and log on to this site, posted by our member pkalra.

http://www.sanctuaryasia.com/takeact...n_keoladeo.php

Just add your own personal comments in the space provided.

I'm not sure if this will make a difference but I hope someone is listening!


All times are GMT +6.5. The time now is 08:44.


© IndiaMike.com 2018


Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.2