Is poop an indicator of health?

hollow

On a show I saw a while back, a guest was selling a book and said if it sinks you are unhealthy and if it floats you are healthy. And that vegatarians are healthier.

So since indian food is normally veggie, how is everyone doing? Are we all floaters here?

Anyone heard that theory before? About the sinking poop = bad health and the floating poop = good health?

Shaktipalooza

bloody poop with worms intertwined = bad health

the rest of the indicators are dodgy.

just thought i'd help turn the conversation down a couple of notches. thank you, drive through please...

__________________
IndiaGroove - Train finder now in beta!
Pics from India 2006
Traditional Indian Dance

jjacquemain

Things go in....Things go out......That's good. I'd have to agree that worms and blood are NOT healthy. Don't really care or thought about the float factor, could be in denial though. (Don't ask, don't tell.)

__________________
There is no defense against chaos~

shpatel

Floating poop=gas in stools....if you actually watch your floating poop you'll see bubbles rising out of it and it will eventually, if left alone, sink to the bottom. Another trivial fact picked up in med school

__________________
Let the world change you...and you can change the world
-Ernesto Guevara de la Serna

Shaktipalooza

I always thought that meant you at a decent amount of fiber?

Casey

I had an Inuit friend from up North in Canada and she told me the same thing about floaters vs sinkers. I doubt it was an old Inuit tale as I don't think they had the luxury of looking in a toilet before flushing. It's pretty damned cold up there! Perhaps, if you know if you are a floater or sinker you have too much time on your hands.

shpatel

Nope, whether its a floater or a sinker is absolutely no indication of how healthy you are or the status of your bowels. Another myth busted

sunilg

hi there,

ur poop is surely an indicator of ur health..

but this floating-sinking thing is something i've never heard till now in medical field......may be i am lil outdated.....

however, the main things to look out when you poop are:
1.) Moving your bowels at regular intervals, at least once daily is indicator of clean system; in some cases may be once in 2 days. Frequency lesser than this is an indicator of something wrong.

2.) Stool caliber and consistency....... large-caliber and hard stool are an indicator of some sort of obstruction..on the other hand, thin and water-consistency stool might be an indicator of some infectious process going on.

3.) Color. Yellow is perfectly fine, might be a little darker or lighter, varies from person to person. watch out for too dark color, like greenish or reddish..if this is case, consult your doctor immediately.

4. ) Check your toilet bowl regularly before flushing, especially person older than 60 years. Watch out for blood, pus, etc. Lower GI tract ulcers occur mostly in this age group. these ulcers are strong risk-factor for cancer in this age group.


Remember, just drinking lots of water daily helps keeping your system clean and problem free.

Also, person in 60+ age group need to have regular blood tests done to detect any bleeding in GI tract.


Bowel habits vary from person to person, so consult your doctor before reaching any conclusion.

Think healthy, stay healthy

__________________
...Bismillah

sticky

And Mr Hankey says.... Heidi Ho children - you should watch out for me.... Heidi Ho

__________________
->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->->

Flashpackers: Backpackers doing it in style.

bijapuri

you know you're with India hands when this kind of discussion occurs at a dinner in a restaurant, isn't it

__________________
Focusing your life solely on making a buck shows a certain poverty of ambition. It asks too little of yourself. Because it's only when you hitch your wagon to something larger than yourself that you realize your true potential.
Barack Obama

lookit me!!!: http://www.flickr.com/photos/bijapuri/

Utube fuzzy logic:
http://youtube.com/profile_videos?user=bijapuri&p =r

lotus blossom

the colon does determine the health of the individual but here is a bit more on the original question (plus more):

YOUR STOOLS CAN REVEAL A LOT ABOUT YOUR HEALTH, IF YOU LEARN TO READ THEM.

LET'S FACE IT: DIGESTION HAPPENS. Few of us, however, are able to talk about the end result without embarrassment. It's too bad we're not more willing to pay attention to our stools, because they may be just as useful in diagnosing our health as taking our temperature or our blood pressure. "People can tell a measure of their health by their bowel movement," says Ted Loftness, M.D., an internist in Litchfield, Minn. "Nothing is so overrated as sex and so underrated as a good bowel movement."

From your stool you may be able to get clues about your diet, your gastrointestinal health, and even whether your stress, anger, or anxiety levels are too high.

HOW FOOD BECOMES STOOL From the moment food enters your mouth, your body embarks on a campaign to turn it into a soupy mush called chyme. Chewing, saliva, peristalsis (the involuntary contractions of gastrointestinal muscles), bacteria, hydrochloric acid, digestive enzymes, bile, and other secretions all work to give each meal the consistency of split pea soup. While your digestive

cells are absorbing sugars, starches, fats, vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients, waste products continue traveling down the line. In the colon, all the leftovers are combined, packed together, and partially dehydrated. What remain--our feces--consist of water, indigestible fiber, undigested food (such as corn and small seeds), sloughed-off dead cells, living and dead bacteria, intestinal secretions, and bile. (The worn-out red blood cells in bile give excrement its distinctive brown color.)

If all goes as it should, you'll end up with a healthy bowel movement. Although digestive idiosyncrasies, variations in intestinal bacteria, and other variables can produce different standards for a healthy stool, in general it should be brown to light brown; formed but not hard; cylindrical, not flattened; fairly bulky and full-bodied, not compacted; somewhat textured but not too messy; and very easy to pass. And it shouldn't smell--much. "You're passing methane and bacterial, degraded foodstuffs, so there's always going to be an odor," says Patrick Donovan, N.D., a naturopath in Seattle. "But it shouldn't be a very strong, pungent odor."

Experts disagree on two other stool characteristics: the number of pieces and their buoyancy. Each bowel movement preferably should be in one piece, about the shape and size of a banana and tapered at the end, according to Melanie Ferreira, a nutritionist and instructor at the Natural Gourmet Institute for Food and Health in New York City. Others, however, object. "Stools don't have to be well-formed logs," Donovan says. "They can disperse in the toilet water; they can break down."

As for "floating versus sinking," one school argues that stools should float. Ferreira says buoyancy is a sign that the body has absorbed the minerals in the food and that these nutrients are not contained in the waste. Another camp believes healthy bowel movements should touch bottom because of their bulk and fiber content. Loftness is not impressed with either argument: "Most stools will sink," he says. "Whether it floats or sinks really doesn't seem to make any difference."

An occasional deviation from this total picture is usually considered okay; chronic deviations (or any featuring blood) are not, and should be checked with a doctor. For a list of specific characteristics that may point to health problems, see our chart below.

If Your Stool Looks... It Could Mean...

BLACK, TARRY, AND STICKY Bleeding in your upper digestive
tract. The black color comes from
digested blood cells.

VERY DARK BROWN You drank red wine last night or
have too much salt or not enough
vegetables in your diet.

GLOWING RED OR MAGENTA You've eaten a lot of reddish foods
such as beets.

LIGHT GREEN You're consuming too much sugar, or
too many fruits and vegetables with
not enough grains or salt.

PALE OR CLAY-COLORED Minimal amounts of bile are being
excreted, perhaps because of problems
with the gallbladder or liver.

BLOODY OR MUCUS-COVERED Hemorrhoids, an overgrowth of certain
bacteria in your gastrointestinal
tract, colitis (inflammation of the
colon), Crohn's disease (also known as
inflammatory bowel disease), or colon
cancer. Red blood usually means the
ailment is located near the end of
your digestive tract, whereas black
blood signals partially digested blood
coming from an ailment higher up the
tract. Seek medical advice promptly.

PENCIL-THIN AND RIBBONLIKE A polyp or growth in your colon that
narrows the passage for stool.

LARGE AND FLOATING, WITH Malabsorption--your digestive system
GREASY FILM ON TOILET WATER isn't getting the full nutritional use
of food.

LOOSE AND WATERY, SOMETIMES Diarrhea. Possible causes are food ,
WITH UNDIGESTED FOODSTUFFS poisoning lactose intolerance,
antibiotics, antacids, dietary
changes, travel, anxiety, stress,
inflammatory bowel disease, or
irritable bowel syndrome.

SMALL, HARD, ROUND PELLETS Constipation--even if you're
defecating frequently. Possible causes
are eating too much dry food,
including protein, and not enough
vegetables and raw foods; laxative
abuse; worries; or irritable bowel
syndrome.

ALTERNATING BOUTS OF Irritable bowel syndrome. This chronic
DIARRHEA AND CONSTIPATION condition can be aggravated by red
meat, spices, sugar, alcohol, lack of
fiber, allergy-causing foods,
irregular hours, and chaotic
relationships.

REALLY BAD-SMELLING An imbalance of intestinal bacteria or
eating too much animal protein, which
can putrefy in your digestive tract.
WHEN MOVEMENTS STALL One of the most common gastrointestinal complaints is hard feces and infrequent and difficult elimination --better known as constipation. If chronic, it may contribute to autoimmune diseases and colon or breast cancer. "The longer stool stays in the colon, the more one reabsorbs some of the metabolic products [such as estrogen] that have been excreted in the bile," says Donovan, who treats people with cancer in his naturopathic clinic. "We can see increased risk of breast cancer in women with a history of constipation."

Experts agree that regularity is important, but they disagree sharply how often the average person should eliminate. The National Institute for Diabetes, Kidney, and Digestive Diseases says three times a week is normal and healthy for some people. According to Ayurveda, the Indian healing system, once a day provides an ideal, complete evacuation, says Virender Sodhi, M.D., an Ayurvedic doctor and naturopath in Bellevue, Wash. Ferreira thinks once or twice a day is the right frequency, while Donovan says a person should have a bowel movement within two to three hours of a major meal--or two to three times a day.

Regular bowel movements may contribute to more than better physical health. "The act of digestion and elimination can be seen as a metaphor for our ability to absorb what is useful from our experiences and eliminate what is unnecessary, harmful, or holds us back," Ferreira says. "If you have a healthy bowel movement each day, you're letting go of the past and bringing in the new."

IMPROVING YOUR STOOL The three basics required for healthy bowel movements (and a healthy digestive system) are fiber, fluids, and exercise. If your stool doesn't fit the profile of a healthy bowel movement, the following steps can make it better.

* Eat more dietary fiber found in whole foods, especially grains, vegetables, and fruits. Fiber allows waste to pass through your digestive system smoothly and quickly.

* Drink plenty of fluids (preferably water, as opposed to sugary drinks) to prevent intestinal blockage from excess fiber.

* Exercise daily. Even a walking program, Loftness says, promotes bowel regularity.

__________________
Not all who wander are lost

kiwi_razz

Also a couple of points on color:

If its black, or a combination black/brown - remember you drank a number of pints of guinness the night before.

If the water has turned a red colour - then after a split second of paranoia remember you had beetroot the night before.

Aparajith

Wow lot to learn lot learn. Now I need to always switch the light in the Toilet

AvidTrekker

Excellent coverage by lotus blossom in "The Bowl Truth"!!

Any Indian Ayurvedic novice will tell you "floaters = good"

I use the "stool questionnaire" to determine acidosis or alkalosis in my patients. The same finding also helps in checking my trekking-group-members' health-check every trekking day. This is very useful for knowing whether a person is acclimatizing properly.

In my last trek, going up to 5319m [17446 feet] my group followed my garlic remedy [some with very yuuuuck faces] and acclimatized very well. This was borne out by their stool reports every day. There were three newcomers [1st time Himaalaya] incl. one female out of eleven in my group. They fared fairly well.

I teach this "stool thing" in my class. lotus-blossom has covered everything except the acidosis v/s. alkalosis parts and its subsequent practical application in day to day living, as also in trekking/mountaineering. This is an endless subject for jokes among all my trek pals.

__________________
The Universe is an ellipsoid?... or a Spheroid?? If the sphere smiles... it becomes an ellipse. This IS Creation.

iwanttogoback

and you know when you're home because people look at you strangely when you start discussing the state of your bowels.